Gattaca ethical implication of genetic determinism

Gattaca (1997)

As he does so, we see Jerome don his silver medal, climb into an incinerator, and turn it on. The resulting embryos are then screened for genetically superior offspring.

Natural and sexual selection is a process based on the choosing of traits perceived to enhance our genetic fitness. Even if early childhood interventions did lead to a positive outcome the evidence is unambiguous in its failure to lead to sustainable positive improvementit would lag behind the efficacy of genetic selection Bostrom This reading effectively emphasizes the fact that the dominant ethical consensus associated with eugenics is by no means static and, as such, much be taken Gattaca ethical implication of genetic determinism the context of wider national and global trends and events.

A relatively limited number of human genes have variants that give rise to an inherited condition not influenced by additional genes or by the environment. The show, and this episode which serves as a series introduction, follows a group of high school students who are direct clones of major historical figures Joan of Arc, Gandhi, John F.

That is, with the information available they selected the embryo with the best characteristics which would allow their child the best quality of life Even today, biometric identification based on fingerprints, hand geometry, iris or retina scans, or facial recognition provides a cheap and accurate way of verifying identity.

But we still give some thought to where the future could be heading, and how scientists who believe in random evolution will contradict their convictions and attempt to direct the evolution Of the human species. Eugenics fundamentally implies the notion that better genes will inevitably lead to better people; a notion that directly ties into the idea of absolute genetic determinism and, furthermore, personal freedom we all do technically have the freedom to be terrible people after all.

And it has some important consequences for genome ethics. There is significant evidence that shortages in the diet of Northern Europeans 5, years ago led to the gene LCT being positively selected, allowing for lactose tolerance into adulthood Akey Scientific American Magazine, May The arc of the story pits a courageous character and a handful of allies against a regime that the film shows has made tragic errors in judgement.

Gattaca is a landmark film that has had widespread impact. Among these which have already been introduced earlier in the course are the concept of race as being determined, not by genetic makeup, but by environmental factors that influence external features, the idea that an individual can be identified based on their DNA, and, finally, the close relation between human nature genetics and behavior which led to the field of sociobiology.

Human genome sequencing: the real ethical dilemmas

This topic, therefore, concerns the very idea by which we as a collective identity define ourselves as humans. As mentioned above, embryo screening for a very wide range of traits is offered. There is also evidence that the constitution of the inner ear has undergone recent selection in the last 30, years as a result of new complexities of speech and language 4.

When his dream was crashing down around him and he could do no ore for himself, he found his fellow humans were there to help him. The Ethics of Human Genetic Modification. One of the problems glossed over in the film is that the supply of eggs from an individual donor is very limited.

Therefore, to consider environmental enhancement as desirable but not a genetic enhancement is irrational, subject to the status quo bias and unscientific.

To do otherwise would be to implicitly harm the child and to be subject to the status quo bias.The world of Gattaca is a dystopia based on absolute genetic determinism. Couples seeking to give their child the best possible chance conceive by in vitro fertilization (IVF).

The resulting embryos are then screened for genetically superior offspring. Gattaca is Wrong: The Moral & Gattaca’s portrayal of genetic determinism has not just influenced popular culture to a degree but the legal and medical professions.

the societal implication of genetic embryo selection should be based on the same societal implications as environmental policies to raise IQ and life outcomes in the. Gattaca () is an extrapolative science fiction film that portrays a dystopian fictional world for genetic discrimination, but a utopian society with regards to racial harmony.

In the film the unenhanced character, Vincent, utilizes the DNA of a. Although GATTACA succeeds in its social criticism of genetic determinism, its extrapolation of a eugenic world from trends in geneticization ignores the equally problematic contemporary trend.

The closest you might get is free will vs. fate at the hands of a greater being (eg, Final Destination), free will vs.

fate at the hands of our own nature (eg, Terminator 2) and free will vs.


genetic determinism (eg, Gattaca). Genetic Passing, Identity, and the Science of Race David A. Kirby.

many television news programs highlight the ethical issues associated with human genetic engineering by showing clips of the film, Rather than serving as another popular culture ally for genetic determinism, GATTACA provides a powerful counterexample.

Gattaca ethical implication of genetic determinism
Rated 0/5 based on 84 review